MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail
Sign in to Windows Live ID Web Search:   
go to MSNGroups 
Groups Home  |  My Groups  |  Language  |  Help  
 
Breeding tropical fishBreedingtropicalfish@groups.msn.com 
  
What's New
  Join Now
  Home Page  
  Copyright Notice  
  Our Group  
  Our Awards  
  Meet the Managers  
  Members = *3854*  
  Message Boards  
  Help Desk  
  Pictures  
  Site Map  
  Search this Site  
  M.O.M  
  Bookshop  
  Chat Times  
  Terminology  
  Ichthyology  
  Beginners Guide  
  
  Choosing Tank  
  
  Siting  
  
  Setting up  
  
  Tank Cycling  
  
  NewTankSyndrome  
  
  Water Changes  
  
  First Fish  
  
  Fish To Avoid  
  
  Maintenance  
  
  Filters  
  
  Filtration  
  
  Aeration  
  
  Food & Feeding  
  
  LiveFood Cultures  
  
  Live food  
  
  Brineshrimps  
  
  Cleaning Live Food  
  
  BasicWaterChemistry  
  
  Salt. Yes or no  
  Water Chemistry  
  ?Fish Health  
  ?A to Z of Fishes  
  ?Tropical fish  
  MarineFishkeeping  
  Coldwater Fish  
  Pondkeeping  
  Breeding Basics  
  Tips and Tricks  
  Members Profiles  
  Clubs Page  
  Retailers  
  Links  
  Reproductive Failure  
  
  
  Tools  
 

 Salt Yes or No?
 
This debate seems to go on and on, here are the facts, as I understand them. There are two types of fresh water fish

  1. Primary freshwater fish
  2. Secondary freshwater fish

Primary freshwater fish evolved in freshwater and have no physiological adaptations to cope with salt.

Secondary freshwater fish have ancestors that moved into freshwater from the sea, and adapted to freshwater conditions, this group still retain some ability to cope with salt in their water.

Salt has a multitude of uses in the aquarium, treating disease, reducing the toxicity of nitrite and so on. It should not be used routinely in the freshwater aquarium. Some fish that are commonly classed as freshwater fish (some Livebearers), are in fact brackish water fish, and of course these do need salt in the water for their well being.

So why do so many people, and so many books recommend it? I think the answer to that comes from the past when the biological process within the filter was poorly understood, and fish were routinely exposed to nitrite in their water. Salt greatly reduces the toxicity of nitrite so fish in aquariums that had salt added would appear to do better than the ones that didn’t. The same argument could also be applied to goldfish kept in a bowl and cleaned out once a week ( the water quality must have been horrendous). Even today I am informed that breeders of Bettas recommend using it, but they keep their males in small unfiltered tanks, so once again there could be a reason why salt appears to help.

If you have good water quality in your tank, and you keep only true freshwater fish. You should not add any salt to the water. Not only does it not serve any useful purpose it will lower the Oxygen carrying capacity of the water and it will stress the fish.

Back to Beginners Guide

Notice: Microsoft has no responsibility for the content featured in this group. Click here for more info.
  Try MSN Internet Software for FREE!
    MSN Home  |  My MSN  |  Hotmail  |  Search
Feedback  |  Help  
  ©2005 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.  Legal  Advertise  MSN Privacy