Histrionic Personality Disorder
Definition
Histrionic personality disorder is typified by attention-seeking behaviors and over-emotionality.
Diagnostic Criteria
The DSM-IV diagnostic criteria define histrionic personality disorder as a pervasive pattern of excessive emotionality and attention seeking that has begun by early adulthood and is present in a variety of contexts. At least five of the following features must be present:
- the person is uncomfortable if he or she is not the center of attention;
- the person's interactions with others often involves inappropriate sexually seductive or provocative behavior;
- the person displays rapidly shifting and shallow emotions;
- the person consistently uses his or her physical appearance to draw attention to himself or herself;
- the person's speech is overly impressionistic and lacking in detail;
- the person displays self-dramatization, theatricality and exaggerated expressions of emotion;
- the person is easily influenced by others or by circumstances;
- the person thinks that relationships are more intimate than they really are.
The ICD-10 diagnostic criteria are virtually identical. However, they do not contain the feature of speech being overly impressionistic and lacking in detail, and only three of the character traits are required for diagnosis.
Symptoms and Signs
People with histrionic personality disorder have a need to be the center of attention and often dress and behave in ways to attract attention - they are often the `life and soul of the party'.
Their emotionality is often excessive and dramatic but lacks depth of feeling. They are frequently stylish and use language in a colorful manner, sprinkled with the latest faddish colloquialisms and slang.
They may spend an inordinate amount of time or money on clothes and grooming. They may look for compliments about their appearance and may be overly upset by a remark they regard as critical or a photograph that seems to show them in an unflattering light.
They may be dramatic, flirtatious or even openly seductive.
In the clinical setting, they are often flattering to the clinician and other staff, may arrive with gifts, and often provide dramatic and colorful physical and psychological symptoms that tend to be new with each visit. They may be inappropriately sexually provocative in their behavior in the clinical setting.
They are often naïvely suggestible and may be a victim of sexual predators or `con men'. There may be frequent, apparently intense but brief romantic or sexual relationships. Promiscuity is common, as are multiple marriages.
Compared with normal women, women with histrionic personality disorder tend to have:
- lower sexual assertiveness and greater erotophobic attitudes toward sex;
- lower self-esteem;
- greater marital dissatisfaction but greater sexual preoccupation;
- lower sexual desire;
- more sexual boredom;
- orgasmic dysfunction;
- extramarital affairs.
Speech and thinking tend to driven by emotionality rather than by logic, and detail is often lacking. Strong opinions may be expressed with few underlying reasons being given for the opinion. Decisions are often made impulsively by `intuition' or `hunches'.
Their behavior may be embarrassing to others with what come to be regarded as excessive public displays of emotion (such as embracing even casual acquaintances, sobbing and crying on minor sentimental occasions, or displaying excessive temper on minor provocation).
Investigations
The diagnosis of histrionic personality disorder is best made by a careful review of the patient's life history, supplemented if possible by the reports of others such as family members.
Enquiries into the characteristics of the patient's family system often reveal well-played roles and marks (e.g. `great seducer father', `very depressed mother') and can give the therapist a different interpretation of the case.
Formal psychological testing may be useful. There are no specific laboratory tests.
Complications
Comorbidity
A number of conditions are frequently comorbid with histrionic personality disorder, including:
- somatization disorder;
- conversion disorder;
- major depressive disorder;
- other personality disorders (especially antisocial, borderline, dependent and narcissistic personality disorders).
People with histrionic personality disorder are at risk of substance abuse, including habituation to prescribed medication. Medications with habituation potential (e.g. benzodiazepines and opiate analgesics) are relatively contraindicated in these patients.
Behavioral Outcomes
Behavioral outcomes that are commonly seen in people with histrionic personality disorder include:
- promiscuity and an increased risk of sexually transmitted diseases;
- relationship problems and an increased incidence of divorce;
- financial irresponsibility and hardship;
- poor employment record.
Differential Diagnosis
The differential diagnosis of histrionic personality disorder include:
- normal histrionic personality traits;
- other personality disorders (e.g. antisocial, borderline, dependent and narcissistic personality disorders - if criteria one or more personality disorders in addition to histrionic personality disorder are met, all can be diagnosed);
- behavioral effects of substance misuse (e.g. cocaine);
- personality change caused by a general medical condition.
Prognosis
Patients with mild forms of histrionic personality disorder benefit from therapy in terms of increased quality of interpersonal relationships and decreased somatization. Some improvement may occur as the patient gets older and increases in maturity.
Patients with severe forms of histrionic personality disorder and those with associated borderline or antisocial features are prone to continued marital or occupational instability, the effects of substance abuse, acting-out behaviors, and even imprisonment.
Treatment Aims
The aims of treatment are:
- to promote greater organization in the patient's life style;
- to promote increased stability and genuine intimacy in interpersonal relationships;
- to promote the capacity to modulate emotions.
Diet and Lifestyle
Regular life habits should be encouraged, including regular and healthy meals and good sleep hygiene. The histrionic patient often needs help to organize personal finances and work habits.
Pharmacological Treatment
There is no specific pharmacological treatment for histrionic personality disorder. Treatment is non-pharmacological.
Non-Pharmacological Treatment
Individual psychodynamic psychotherapy remains the cornerstone of treatment. It can provide support at times of crisis (e.g. the break-up of a relationship). The therapist can model a well-modulated affective response, and through questions and interpretations can emphasize the need for problem solving and coping strategies rather than the use of emotional displays or somatization. The therapist must also carefully redirect the patient to resolve the areas of emotional conflict that are characteristically avoided or repressed. Long-term psychotherapy is often necessary. Therapists may benefit from special training in this area.
Other therapies that may be useful include:
- group therapy, which may be an useful adjunct to individual therapy in that the group may confront the patient, in a supportive manner, about issues of emotionality and manipulative behavior;
- marital therapy;
- familial therapy orientated to the characteristics of the patient's family system;
- behavioral therapy, which can help to treat acute symptoms (e.g. somatic symptoms, suicide gestures), particularly during inpatient treatment.
It is worth noting that the histrionic patient is likely to attempt to subvert therapy and make it into a social event. Seductive behavior can not only circumvent the therapeutic process but, if the therapist succumbs, can lead to disaster for both patient and therapist.
Follow-Up and Management
In the Acute Phase
People with histrionic personality disorder frequently present at times of severe emotional distress, often caused by disrupted interpersonal relationships. Supportive care, at times inpatient psychiatric treatment, is required for stabilization.
In the Longer Term
Long-term psychotherapy (months to years) to address is usually needed after acute episodes of emotionalism or somatization have been stabilized. Even after successful moderation of histrionic defenses, some brief psychotherapeutic interventions may be required at times of severe stress or loss.
Etiology
Concepts of histrionic traits as compared with `hysterical' traits have been muddied by the confusing terminology used to describe these patients. Early psychoanalytic theories of fixation at an oedipal level of psychosexual development have largely been discarded.
Current explanations of etiology include the following:
- cultural and sub-cultural differences in the degree of emotional demonstrativeness;
- constitutional temperamental differences in traits such as novelty seeking;
- genetic influences - there is evidence of an increased frequency of histrionic personality disorder and somatization disorder in female relatives and of antisocial personality disorder in male relatives of patients with histrionic personality disorder.
Epidemiology
The prevalence in the general population is 2-3%; in psychiatric patients (when structured assessment instruments are used), the prevalence rises to 10-15%.
The prevalence is higher in females than in males, although there may be a sex bias for females in favor of histrionic personality over antisocial personality.